The Kathryn Stockett Criticism

Posted: August 28, 2011 in Reflections

In an earlier post, I said that “I have no right to write a gangster story (get it?)”. The gangster story, of course, is Reborn City

Well, that bad pun has more relevance than people may think: I’ve mentioned that I’m Caucasian. Not only that, but I’m Jewish, suburban, and a college student to boot. I’m what’s known as privileged. Just like Kathryn Stockett and her novel The Help, I fear that a lot of criticism that’ll come my way if Reborn City ever makes it into the market is that it’s another white writer trying to write in the voice of minorities, and a similar novel written by a black, Hispanic, or Asian writer wouldn’t get the same reaction (I’m just assuming for the moment that Reborn City is at least as popular as The Help).

Maybe so. But I doubt that when Ms. Stockett wrote The Help, her goal was to step on people’s toes like people keep thinking she has. It’s the same with me: I started writing because J.K. Rowling inspired me enough to make me want to compete with her. I got into horror/sci-fi/fantasy because I wanted to emulate writers like Anne Rice, Stephen King, and Dean Koontz. I wrote Reborn City because it seemed like a totally awesome idea, an adventure story involving gangs and mutant-powers and shady governments. And I kept writing it, planning two sequels and sending off part of Reborn City to an agent because at some point, I realized there was an important theme here, among all the other themes I’ve laced into the story: that in the end, you, and only you, are the only person that can control your destiny.

I’m not trying to be like the great white redeemer or whatever, I’m just trying to help people through an engaging story become self-empowered. Is that so bad? And besides, the one who helps the other characters realize this important lesson is an Arab Muslim, and at least a third of the leaders of the main gang in Reborn City are white. So it’s kind of reversed, isn’t it?

And for the record, all writers write their stories becasue they love what they write and want to share it with people just for the story’s sake. Their’s no other ulterior motive behind it. I’ll keep that in mind while I attempt to find a night to go see The Help at the local theater (I’d read the book, but I cringe to think how long the reserve list is at my library!).

Leave a comment