Posts Tagged ‘underrated horror films’

It’s that time of year again, which means it’s time to recommend some movies for spooky season. So once again, I’m here to recommend thirteen movies that you can binge between now and Halloween. Hopefully you decide to check some of these out. As usual, I got a mix of old and new, well-known and lesser-known. All guaranteed to make your spooky season that much spookier.

So are you ready? One. BOO! Three. Let’s go.

I Am A Ghost (2012)
A ghost is haunting an old, rambling Victorian home. However, she doesn’t know she’s dead. Not until a medium reaches out to her to let her know she’s dead and it’s time for her to move on. But that’s easier said than done. Especially given the truth of how she died.

Made for only ten thousand dollars, this little indie film has both a creepy mystery and a distinct style that makes it stand out. Some of the editing choices might not be for everyone, but honestly, it’s stuck in my mind for over ten years. And I think it’s something you’ll enjoy, too, if you give it a chance. Plus, it’s on Tubi, so it’s free.

Screamboat (2025)
An anthropomorphic mouse gets loose on an old Staten Island Ferry vessel, going on a violent murder spree. Hijinks ensue.

These public domain horror films based around characters like Winnie the Pooh and the Steamboat Willie version of Mickey Mouse get a bad reputation. And for the most part, deservedly so. However, this one is actually decent! The humor is top-notch, the slasher element is extremely gory and well done, and there are actually some really beautiful, heartfelt moments. The flooding closet scene alone will pull at your heartstrings! So, if you’re going to check out any of these crazy public domain slashers, make it Screamboat.

Plus, you can make one hell of a drinking game trying to catch all the Disney references. Just saying.

My Best Friend’s Exorcism (2022)
Set in 1989, friends Abby and Gretchen get together with some friends for a weekend of getting into trouble. However, while attempting to take some LSD, something attacks Gretchen. Something not human. It’s making her do horrible things to herself and those around her. It’s trying to drag Gretchen’s soul to Hell. And Abby will need help if she wants to save her best friend from damnation.

Based on the fabulous novel by Grady Hendrix (see my review of the novel here), this movie is equal parts funny and scary, and is also quite heartwarming. My sister and I watched it on a movie night, and she and I loved it. If you’re looking for a fun horror movie to watch this season, then this is definitely an option for you.

Heretic (2024)
A pair of young Mormon women doing their missionary work go to a man’s house after scheduling to meet with him and proselytize to him. However, the man hasn’t asked them to come to his home because he truly is interested in the Book of Mormon. He’s invited them because he’s built his house to be a giant trap. And while they’re stuck with him, they’re going to go on a religious/spiritual journey with him. Whether they want to or not.

With a standout performance by Hugh Grant as antagonist Mr. Reed, the film delivers both a tense atmosphere and a twisty plot full of religious, spiritual, and philosophical themes that really get you thinking. If you enjoy horror but are also very religious/spiritual, I would recommend seeing this film just to ponder its themes. Also, it’s a damn good horror film.

Banshee Chapter (2013)
After her best friend from college mysteriously disappears after taking a chemical associated with the MKUltra experiments, tries to figure out what happened. Along the way, she gets in deep with government conspiracies, a counterculture writer with a drug habit, and mysterious, barely seen creatures that want to inhabit our skins.

Based loosely on the short story “From Beyond” by HP Lovecraft, this found footage updates the story with one of America’s most infamous moments of violating the rights of its own people. It’s not perfect, but it has plenty of scary and tense moments and it’s hard to look away. Plus, Ted Levine as surly counterculture author Thomas Blackburn just steals the show in the best way.

Abigail (2024)
A group of career criminals kidnap a twelve-year-old ballerina to hold her for ransom. They’re told to lay low in a mansion for the next twenty-four hours. No names, no personal details, and no interacting with the girl. However, it soon turns out that the girl is the daughter of a terrifying underworld figure. And she’s a vampire. And she basically staged her own kidnapping so she could have some fun hunting her prey.

As bloody as it is hysterical, this was definitely one of the best horror films of last year. Watching a preteen in a bloody tutu tear out people’s throats and fight grown adults while dancing the steps to Swan Lake is like nothing else. Plus, you really grow to like these characters, even if some of them are total bastards. Give it a watch and see how it enhances your Halloween season.

Alice, Sweet Alice (1976)
Two young girls are growing up in a heavily Catholic community in early 1960s New Jersey. The younger is murdered on the day of her First Communion, and suspicion falls on her older sister Alice, who is neglected and displays antisocial behavior. She also has never been allowed communion, as she was conceived out of wedlock. As more bodies pile up, more fingers start pointing in Alice’s direction. Is she the one behind it all? Or is someone else the culprit?

When this early slasher was released in 1976, it caused an uproar due to its perceived anti-Catholic views. However, it’s since gained a huge cult following and has been examined and reexamined by scholars for what it says about religion, familial dysfunction, and adolescent psychology. For my part, Alice, Sweet Alice has been stuck in my memory since I saw it a few years ago, and I keep finding myself returning to the movie and its troubled main character, every now again.

If you want a slasher that pushes some boundaries, this might be the movie you should watch this spooky season.

In a Violent Nature (2024)
Another prominent slasher, this one takes things in a very different direction. After his grave is disturbed, an undead killer rises from the dead. He then goes on a killing spree, mowing through everyone he comes across. All while doing it in a slow, methodical, unemotional way. And I mean “slow, methodical, unemotional.” But in the most fascinating way.

Most slashers focus on the characters about to be killed, but In a Violent Nature shows things from the killer’s perspective. Not directly, but usually from behind him. Coupled with a lot of quiet moments, without even a soundtrack other than nature sounds, and it makes for a realistic take on a slasher story, though it still has its moments where you think to yourself, “Okay, you idiot, you did something stupid and now you’re going to die.”

Just make sure to be well-rested while watching. If you’re not careful, the quiet moments can put you to sleep.

The Gate (1987)
A young boy and his friend accidentally discover a gateway to semi-Lovecraftian cosmic entities of evil and try to close it before the demons swarm out into our reality and destroy it. Along the way, they’ll deal with some trauma and feelings of loneliness.

This film isn’t the scariest thing I’ve ever seen, but it is fun to watch. It’s filled with a lot of heart, some decent stopmotion effects, and an emotional undertone that will get you right in the feels. Plus, that opening scene that still scares me (plus it inspired a novel I hope to write someday)!

While I wish it would lean more in to the Lovecraftian elements (maybe a remake someday?), it’s still a great film. Give it a watch, and you’ll see.

The Collector (1965)
A man wins the lottery and buys a huge house in the country. He then uses it to keep a woman he’s infatuated with. Obviously, the woman wants nothing to do with him. But stuck in his home, she only has so many options at her disposal. Thus begins a terrible game of cat and mouse.

This psychological horror film may be older and a slow-burn, but it’s still effective. Watching both characters trying to outmaneuver one another and gain control in this messed up stalker-stalkee relationship, all in the background of the English countryside, has to be seen to be believed.

The Vigil (2019)
A young Jewish man who has recently left his ultra-Orthodox community is hired to watch over the body of a recently deceased man until his body is collected in the morning for the funeral. However, the deceased was apparently haunted his whole life by a terrible spirit. And now, the young man may be its next victim.

This is, by far, one of the best examples of Jewish horror films I’ve ever come across. Spooky, atmospheric, with an emphasis on practical effects and psychological horror, this film will stay with you long after you’ve watched it.

The Spanish-Language Dracula (1931)
It’s the same movie you know. The one that started the Universal horror line and is part of the foundation of modern horror films. Or is it?

Back in the 1930s, movie studios were trying to reach foreign markets, especially Spanish-language markets. And rather than dubbing over the soundtracks or figuring out how to put subtitles onscreen, they would have a Spanish-speaking cast and crew come in when the English-language crew were done filming for the day and film their own version. The Spanish-language Dracula is particularly famous, as director George Melford would watch what was filmed the day before to inform his own version.

The result is a version of the 1931 film that is on par with and maybe even better than the English-language version. It was thought lost for many years, but resurfaced in the 1970s and has since been preserved for both posterity and our viewing pleasure. And honestly, if you’ve seen the English version, then you really have to check out the Spanish version and compare the two.

Sinners (2025)
A pair of twins in Jim Crow Alabama decide to open a juke joint for the local African-American community, enlisting the help of their young cousin and some other locals to make it a success. However, on opening night, the joint gets some unexpected gate-crashers in the form of vampires. And these vamps, who are out for more than just blood, won’t stop till they get what they came for.

If you only watch one film off this list–nay, if you watch only one film this Halloween season, make it Sinners. This film is visual, musical, historical, thematic, and just a few other types of gold besides. Blending genres, breaking conventions, and putting a big boost into both African American horror and original horror stories, I’ve seen it twice and have been blown away each and every time.


So, those are my recommendations for this year. I hope you decide to check out a few of these. I know I’ll be giving the ones I haven’t seen in a while a rewatch.

But in the meantime, tell me: what would you add to the list? Which of these films have you seen? And what were your impressions of them? Let’s discuss.

That’s all for now, my Followers of Fear. Until next time, good night, pleasant nightmares, and 75 days till Halloween. Get watching.

Today, I saw a full Halloween display in a supermarket. You know what that means. As of today, the Halloween season has officially begun! That’s right, it’s here! Break out the candy, dress up as something scary, carve up your pumpkins, and decorate your house like the Addams are coming to visit! Who cares if there’s a pandemic right now? We can still celebrate the season.

That being said, you’re probably wondering to yourself, what horror films should I watch this year? I’m sure plenty of you will be watching classics and beloved staples of horror/the season. Believe me, I will be too. But there are a bunch of films that don’t get as much love as they should. So I’ve come up with 11 films I feel would make great viewing for this year. Why 11? Because THERE’S SOMETHING WITH FANGS BEHIND YOU!

Anyway, on with the list. And in no particular order, might I add.

11. Overlord

A team of American soldiers parachute into Nazi-controlled France hours before D-Day to take down an operations center inside a church. However, the church is also being used to perform inhuman experiments in life after death. And if the soldiers don’t do something, the fate of the world might be at stake.

Whenever somebody talks about Nazi zombies, it’s usually in humorous terms. That, and the trailers for this film were all over the place, so nobody was really sure what audience this film was meant for. Horror? Action? War? Which is a shame, because Overlord is one of the best horror films I’ve ever seen. Its sets are atmospheric, the zombies are only used enough to be scary, and there’s an emphasis on psychological and war horror rather than guts and gore (though there’s plenty of that).

Make sure to check Overlord out. You won’t regret adding it to your watchlist.

10. As Above, So Below

An archaeologist leads a team into the Paris catacombs to find an ancient artifact. However, they stumble upon a gateway to hell, where their worst fears and guilt are used against them.

Coming out at the tail end of the found footage craze, this film was lost among audiences who were tired of shaky cameras and home video-style films. However, it’s found new life on home media, and it’s not hard to see why. The film takes advantage of its setting to deliver a claustrophobic and unnerving atmosphere. Not only that, but there’s a philosophical bent to the film that I spent discussing with friends for about an hour after we saw the film. It’s not everyday you meet a horror film that makes you think.

9. Carrie (2013)

I know the original Carrie is beloved, but I’ve always preferred the remake with Chloe Grace Moretz and Julianne Moore. Not only are the special effects much better, but none of the strange editing (like that infamous fast forward) and odd creative choices are present. For example, in the original, when Carrie starts her revenge, the students start panicking because the doors won’t open. Yeah, nothing overtly psychic has happened yet, just the doors won’t open. And yet everyone is screaming in terror. Whereas in the remake, the progression from students laughing at Carrie to screaming in fear is much more natural and believable. And Julianne Moore’s interpretation of Margaret White gets her crazy factor across way more than any actress before her. Those factors are why I prefer this version of Carrie, and why I’m recommending it for this Halloween.

8. Underwater

This came out earlier this year and didn’t receive that much fanfare. That being said, it’s become something of a hidden gem within horror. It’s a pretty compelling disaster flick set in an underwater base, with a Lovecraftian twist about halfway through. While it’s not as effective as scaring people as Hereditary or as memorable as 2017’s IT, it’s still a film I recommend you see.

7. Annihilation

Based on the book by Jeff Vandermeer, Annihilation follows a team of scientists into the Shimmer, a strange zone on the West Coast where nature mutates and changes, and perhaps our own selves are at risk of changing. It’s a creepy film with a great group of female leads, as well as a Lovecraftian angle in its approach to body horror and the final twists. In the end, you may have more questions than when you started, but you’ll enjoy the thrill ride along the way. As well as the dark truth hidden in the conclusion.

6. The House of the Devil

A film made to look like it came right out of the 1980s, House of the Devil follows a college student taking on a babysitting job, only to find something very dark at the heart of her assignment. You’d never guess it was filmed in 2009. Also, it’s damn hard to look away. A supernatural slow burn that lures you in and ends up surprising you with how terrifying it can be. I’m sad that it’s flown under the radar so much, but that’s why I’m happy to post about it and recommend it this Halloween season.

5. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Based on the graphic novel by Allen Moore, several of the greatest figures from 19th century literature come together to stop a terrorist from causing WWI fifteen years early. It didn’t do as well in theaters, but it’s become rather beloved since it came out on video. Action and horror, intrigue and steampunk/Victorian aesthetics. I swear, if this came out today rather than in the early 2000s, it might be something of a hit (though I do admit, its slow moments do bring down the film a bit).

Hell, my siblings and I nearly had a fist fight over our mom’s DVD copy when she was downsizing, we loved it that much. And half my sisters don’t even like horror! Given that, shouldn’t you check it out?

4. Van Helsing

Bram Stoker’s vampire hunter is reimagined as a badass monster hunter played by Hugh Jackman, going up against Dracula as the latter tries to bring a terrible plan to fruition.

A lot of people give this film flack, but I love it. It’s a great action-horror flick along the lines of the previous entry, and was one of my favorites as a teenager. It may be over the top, but if you’re looking for popcorn horror at its best, you could do a lot worse than Van Helsing.

3. Devil

Five people get on an elevator, only for them to get stuck and picked off by a supernatural entity. The devil has come for sinners, and it’s not going to stop till it has all of them.

This was originally supposed to be part of a trilogy, but M. Night Shamaylan, who directed the first film, was unable to follow it up. That being said, I find this film to be creepy and a lot of fun to watch. It takes an interesting concept and adds a time-is-running-out element to it. I loved it when I first saw it, and I still kind of like it. Maybe you will too.

2. The Reaping

A professional debunker of miracles is called to a small town in Louisiana when a little girl is accused of killing her brother and bringing the ten plagues upon the town. There, she finds a Satanic cult devoted to bringing about the end of the world, and this girl may be the vehicle to do so.

The mystery of the film isn’t that hard to figure out, but the film has its moments and its got some great performances from Hillary Swank, AnnaSophia Robb, and Idris Elba before he was famous. Plus, when you reach the end of the film and realize the final twist, 2020 as a whole makes a lot more sense (you’ll have to watch the film to get what I mean).

1. Clown

Released three years before 2017’s IT, Clown follows a man who puts on a clown suit he finds for his child’s birthday. However, what he doesn’t know is that the suit is cursed, and is slowly transforming him into a child-eating monster. This is a bloody and terrifying monster movie with lots of effective body horror, and I’m honestly surprised more people haven’t heard of it. Hence why I’m recommending it here.

 

That wraps up my list. I hope it gave you some ideas of what to check out this year. But tell me, what are you planning on watching this Halloween season? Any other films I missed that should be on this list? Let’s discuss.

That’s all for now, my Followers of Fear. Until next time, stay safe, pleasant nightmares, and no opening doors to Hell without me there. I make it a lot more fun.